Pin finishes
Soft Enamel vs
Hard Enamel Pins.
Both are die-struck metal pins filled with colored enamel — the difference comes down to how that enamel is finished. Here's what actually changes between the two, and how to decide which one fits your design.
Side by side
| Factor | Soft enamel | Hard enamel |
|---|---|---|
| Texture feel | Recessed colors you can feel — a slightly textured, tactile surface | Flush and smooth — no texture, feels like glass or polished metal |
| Surface finish | Enamel sits below the raised metal lines | Enamel is polished level with the metal for a seamless surface |
| Cost | Lower cost — fewer production steps | Modest premium over soft enamel — extra polishing and baking steps |
| Design complexity | Great for bold, simple shapes and flat color blocks | Handles fine detail and sharp color separation better |
| Best for | Everyday pins, brand merch, high-volume giveaways | Premium collectibles, corporate awards, detailed logos |
What is soft enamel?
A soft enamel pin starts as a die-struck metal base, where your design is pressed into the metal to form raised outlines and recessed cells. Colored enamel is then hand-poured into those recessed cells and cured, but it isn't polished flush afterward — the enamel sits slightly below the metal lines, so the raised borders are visible and touchable.
That recessed structure is what gives soft enamel its signature textured feel, and it's also what keeps costs down — there's no extra polishing step. It works especially well for bold, graphic designs with clearly separated color fields, which is why it's the most common finish for brand merch, event pins, and everyday giveaways.
What is hard enamel?
Hard enamel (sometimes called cloisonné) starts the same way — a die-struck metal base with enamel poured into the recessed cells. The difference is what happens next: the pin is baked and polished multiple times until the enamel is ground down level with the metal, producing a completely smooth, glass-like surface with no texture or raised lines to feel.
Those extra baking and polishing passes are what let hard enamel hold finer detail and sharper color separation, and why it reads as the more premium finish. It's the common choice for corporate award pins, detailed logos, and collectible-grade designs where a flush, polished surface matters.
Which should I choose?
- Your design uses bold shapes and flat color blocks
- You want the lowest per-unit cost
- You like the textured, tactile feel
- You're ordering high volume for giveaways or merch
- Your logo or design has fine detail or thin lines
- You want a smooth, glass-like, premium surface
- It's a corporate award or collectible-grade piece
- Color count and separation are more important than cost
Not sure which finish suits your design?
Let the AI recommend one based on your logo — describe or upload your design and get a finish recommendation along with your first concepts.
Start designing free →Enamel finish FAQ
Which enamel type is more durable?
Is soft enamel or hard enamel more expensive?
Can I feel the difference between soft and hard enamel?
Which type is better for a detailed logo?
Can the AI tell me which finish is right for my design?
Do both finishes have the same minimum order quantity?
Ready to design your pin?
The AI will help you pick the right finish — no account required to start.
Open the designer →